A federal appeals court has dealt a serious legal blow to Pete Hegseth and Donald Trump by mostly preventing the administration from kicking transgender service members out of the military. In a 107-page ruling, the court not only rejects the policy but also carefully breaks it down and highlights the blatant discrimination behind it.
The court’s wording is striking.
It points out that Trump “declared transgender people as categorically unfit for military service explicitly because of their gender identity.” To make matters worse, the President described transgender individuals as dishonorable, undisciplined, arrogant, selfish liars.
These aren’t just the court’s views on Trump’s policy; they are his own words.
Regarding the specific Hegseth policy, the court was just as harsh.
The Pentagon’s rule “disqualified all persons with any history of gender dysphoria, regardless of how long ago they had been stable and symptom-free — even if diagnosed as a child.” This means that even if someone hasn’t had symptoms or treatment in years, they would still be disqualified forever.
The court summed up its ruling with a powerful statement: “Unless we are going to fall for the old Groucho Marx line — ‘who are you going to believe, me or your lying eyes?’
— we have direct evidence in this case that animus motivated the classifications in the Hegseth Policy.”
“Animus” is a legal term for unfair discrimination based on hostility rather than genuine government concern.
A federal appeals court has concluded that Pete Hegseth’s military policy was driven by animus — hatred disguised as policy.
The court determined that the plaintiffs — around 4,200 transgender service members currently serving in the U.S. military — are likely to win their argument that the policy violates the equal protection rights guaranteed by the Constitution.
The ruling stops the administration from removing current transgender service members while allowing the ban on new recruits to remain in place as the case moves forward.
“This is a huge relief for these service members and their families,” attorney Shannon Minter said.
These individuals chose to serve their country, and while Trump called them liars, the federal appeals court recognized that for what it truly is.
The case might eventually be taken up by the Supreme Court, but for now, the Constitution has prevailed.
About the Author
