Senator Mark Kelly delivered a blistering assessment of Donald Trump’s war with Iran during a campaign appearance in Maine, accusing the president of launching a conflict without a coherent strategy and leaving American service members and families to pay the price.
The Arizona Democrat, a retired Navy combat pilot and former astronaut, was campaigning Wednesday for Democratic Senate candidate Troy Jackson in Brunswick, Maine, when he turned his attention to the war that has dominated much of Trump’s second term.
Kelly did not mince words.
“We had a President take this country to war without a strategic goal, without a plan, without a timeline, and without an exit strategy. And now he’s stuck. He doesn’t know what to do,” Kelly said.
The criticism carried particular weight coming from a senator who serves on both the Senate Armed Services Committee and the Senate Intelligence Committee.
Kelly argued that the administration had failed to demonstrate why a major military confrontation was necessary or what a successful conclusion would look like.
“I sit on the Armed Services and the Intelligence Committees, both of them. And I will say, from what I know about this, the Iranians weren’t any closer to developing a nuclear weapon this year than they were when I first got to the United States Senate in 2020,” Kelly said, according to the account of his remarks.
He also pointed to Trump’s 2018 decision to withdraw the United States from the nuclear agreement with Iran, arguing that the move helped create the conditions for Tehran to increase its uranium enrichment.
“And it’s this President who, by the way, tore up the deal in 2018 that started them to enrich the uranium at a higher level,” Kelly said.
“So if you think there was a problem, this President created the problem!”
Kelly’s assessment of Iran’s nuclear progress is his own intelligence-informed judgment. It does not establish that the country’s nuclear activities presented no security risk, and the administration has defended its military actions as necessary to protect American interests.
But Kelly’s central argument was that the president had chosen a costly military confrontation without establishing a clear path toward ending it.
“But he didn’t need to go to war and put Americans in harm’s way,” Kelly continued. “We have now 20 deceased service members. Over 800 injured.”
Those figures reflected Kelly’s stated assessment of American casualties. The precise totals can change as the conflict continues.
The senator then connected the human cost of the war to the financial pressures facing ordinary Americans.
“And what did the American people get out of this?” Kelly asked. “They got nothing. They got higher gas prices. They got higher food prices.”
The conflict has disrupted energy markets, contributing to higher fuel costs and putting additional pressure on households already struggling with everyday expenses.
Kelly has made that economic argument repeatedly as he campaigns around the country, accusing Trump and congressional Republicans of pursuing policies that make life more expensive for working families.
But the most emotional portion of his Maine remarks concerned the treatment of American military personnel.
Kelly discussed the extended deployment of the USS Abraham Lincoln carrier strike group, whose sailors have faced unusually demanding conditions during operations connected to the Iran war.
“We’ve got service members deployed for record numbers of days on the USS Abraham Lincoln,” Kelly said.
He then raised a disturbing issue involving the mental health of personnel assigned to the carrier strike group.
“Really, they had eight service members who tried to commit suicide because of the conditions aboard the ship,” Kelly said.
The Navy has confirmed eight suicide attempts across the Lincoln carrier strike group during its extended deployment. Those cases involved personnel across the broader group, not necessarily eight sailors aboard the aircraft carrier itself.
The Navy has also said the number was not outside historical expectations for a deployment of that size, while acknowledging the difficulties of extended operations at sea.
Kelly nevertheless argued that the administration’s public response failed to demonstrate sufficient concern for the personnel involved.
He singled out Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth.
“And I’ve got to tell you, the worst thing about that, by far, for me, was to see the Secretary of Defense go straight to camera and say, there’s no problem, and we give commanders everything they need. That is not leadership.”
For Kelly, the issue was not simply whether military commanders had adequate resources. It was whether the nation’s civilian defense leadership was willing to acknowledge the strain on service members and take responsibility for improving conditions.
“Leadership has taken some responsibility for whatever the situation is,” Kelly said.
He suggested that Hegseth could have responded by acknowledging the problem, promising to examine it and committing to better support for the affected personnel.
“How hard would it have been for him to say, hey, I recognize there’s a problem. We’re going to look into the problem, and we’re going to make things better for these service members because they deserve that,” Kelly asked.
“It’s not hard to do. This Secretary of Defense was incapable of doing that.”
It was a forceful criticism from a former military officer who has spent much of his political career emphasizing the responsibilities of civilian leaders toward the people they send into combat.
Kelly’s comments also came at a politically sensitive moment.
With the November midterm elections approaching, Democrats are increasingly seeking to connect the Iran war to Trump’s broader record on affordability, national security and government accountability.
In Maine, Kelly was campaigning alongside Troy Jackson, the Democratic candidate challenging longtime Republican Senator Susan Collins.
The race has become an important contest for both parties as Democrats attempt to gain ground in the Senate.
Kelly argued that Republicans in Congress had failed to provide adequate checks on Trump’s decisions, while working families were left facing the consequences.
Outside the campaign event, he told reporters that the country was in a difficult position and that families were struggling with the costs of gasoline, housing and everyday necessities.
His appearance with Jackson brought the debate over the war directly into one of the election season’s closely watched Senate contests.
The White House has maintained that its military strategy is intended to protect U.S. security interests and prevent Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons.
Kelly sees the conflict differently.
In a September interview with ABC News, he similarly accused Trump of entering the war without a strategic goal or exit plan, describing the result as a failure of presidential leadership.
Wednesday’s remarks sharpened that criticism by placing the experiences of American service members at the center of the argument.
The senator’s message was that the costs of war cannot be measured solely in military operations or government spending.
They are also measured in lives lost, troops injured, families separated by prolonged deployments and the financial strain experienced by Americans at home.
And with voters preparing to head to the polls, Kelly made clear that he believes the president and his Republican allies should be held politically accountable for those consequences.
His speech in Maine was more than an attack on a foreign-policy decision.
It was a challenge to Trump’s leadership — and to Hegseth’s handling of the Americans serving under his command.
About the Author
